Ozone Hole Excuse For Record Antarctic Ice Blows Up in “Scientists” Faces

The NSIDC and many other used the ozone hole as an “excuse” for why Antarctic Sea Ice Extent broke records this year.

“Both warming and ozone loss act to strengthen the circumpolar winds in the south. This is due primarily to persistently cold conditions prevailing on Antarctica year-round, and a cold stratosphere above Antarctica due to the ozone hole. Stronger winds generally act to blow the sea ice outward, slightly increasing the extent”

Guess what, WUWT tells us it was the 2nd smallest ozone hole in 20 years.

“The average area covered by the Antarctic ozone hole this year was the second smallest in the last 20 years, according to data from NASA and National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) satellites.”

What a shock. The “scientists” excuses for more Antarctic Sea Ice was bogus.

AGW “Experts” Are Idiots!

Experts: Global warming means more Antarctic ice (h/t Marc Morano)

“This subtle growth in winter sea ice since scientists began measuring it in 1979 was initially surprising, they say, but makes sense the more it is studied.”

Translation: It was embarrassing us, so we’ll make something up.

“A warming world can have complex and sometimes surprising consequences,”

Translation: Antarctica is cooling, we don’t know why, so we will claim it is warming.

“”It sounds counterintuitive, but the Antarctic is part of the warming as well.”

Translation: More Ice = Warming and Less Ice = Warming. Our scam wins either way!

“But that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t be paying attention to it and shouldn’t be talking about it.”

Translation: We ignored the records in 2006 and 2012 and finally a few bloggers embarrassed us so much about 2012 that we had our buddy Seth Borenstein make up some crap.

“Antarctica’s weather peculiarities, on the other hand, don’t have much effect on civilization.”

Translation: It threatens our gravy train of grant money so we kept quiet about it.

“And the wind works in combination with the ozone hole, the huge gap in Earth’s protective ozone layer that usually appears over the South Pole”

Translation: We plan to ignore the ozone hole over the Arctic … which we never predicted either.

“Antarctic sea ice is also getting snowier because climate change has allowed the air to carry more moisture.

Guffaw.

“Winter sea ice has grown by about 1 percent a decade in Antarctica. ”

Actually, only one year before 1998 (1980 had 3) had days over 19 million sq km of Antarctic Ice. 2006 had 30 and 2012 had 28.

“computer models have long predicted that Antarctica would not respond as quickly to global warming as other places. ”

Translation; Models said it would melt too. Our models are crap.

“Scientists on the cruise with Maksym are spending eight to 12 hours a day on the ice bundled up against the fierce wind with boots that look like Bugs Bunny’s feet.”

Translation: Clown Feet would be more appropriate.

NSIDC Ignored Antarctica in 2006 Too

Antarctic Sea Ice Extent set an all time record in 2012. The previous record was set in 2006. In 2006 there were 30 days where the ice extent was over 19 million sq km. That record has not been broken and was 9 days more than the previous record holder (1998).

So what did the NSIDC have to say about it in 2006?

Nothing.

They mentioned the Arctic a lot. And Al Gore’s movie. And that there was going to be an open house. But they ignored Antarctica. If they were scientists and not propagandists shouldn’t they be interested in both poles and maximum records too?

 

 

28 days of 19 million sq km Antarctic Sea Ice Extent

Only 9 years in the satellite era have seen Antarctic Sea Ice Extent hit 19 million sq km.  2006 had 30 days. In the last 2 days  2012 has trend up again over 19 million and put it within 2 days of tying the all time record. Aside from 1980, all of those years have been since 1998 which some people claim have been the hottest years in the history of human beings. Antarctic Sea Ice Extent disagrees.

Year Days Above 19 million Last Day Above 19 million
2006 30 283
2012 28 281
1998 21 281
2005 13 278
2009 11 271
2007 9 275
2004 6 254
2000 5 274
1980 3 269

Click for larger …

2012 Highest September Average Antarctic Sea Ice of All Time!

Antarctic Sea Ice Extent for September 2012 averaged 19.1702 million sq km.

That is the highest September average of ALL TIME!!!! (during the satellite era).

Year Average for September (million sq km)
2012 19.1702
2006 19.0932
2009 18.9596
2004 18.9184
1998 18.9027
2000 18.8872
2007 18.8599
1980 18.817
2005 18.8036
2010 18.7979
1985 18.7061
1999 18.6957
2011 18.6937
1996 18.6308
1994 18.6144
1981 18.5972
1997 18.5955
1983 18.5864
1993 18.5438
1995 18.4147
1982 18.3555
1991 18.3121
1988 18.3064
2003 18.299
1987 18.2454
1979 18.1968
1990 18.1924
2001 18.1742
1984 18.166
1992 18.1474
2008 18.1443
1989 18.1194
2002 17.8866
1986 17.6925

NY Times Dishonestly Shills for NSIDC Antarctic Deniers

A few days I asked the question about the record Antarctic Sea Ice Extent in 2012 “Anyone wonder why NOAA isn’t making a fuss about this?”

One caveat is that I should have said NSIDC instead of NOAA (NOAA does partially fund NSIDC).

Today Justin Gillis took a cheap shot at bloggers (h/t Tom Nelson) and said:

“The National Snow and Ice Data Center uses a five-day moving average to track such matters, and always waits a few days before announcing a minimum or maximum in sea ice at either pole. That is to make sure the low or high point for the year has really been reached, given that sea ice can change abruptly in response to winds and other factors. The five-day averaging also helps smooth out small errors in the satellite tracking data.

.

This longstanding practice has been explained publicly many times, but that has not stopped climate-change contrarians from asserting that the snow and ice center had been trying to hide this year’s record in Antarctica by supposedly failing to make any announcement.”

I checked. The Arctic record was broken on the August 24th and NSIDC waited 3 days to call a news conference for the media on the 27th,

The Antarctic Extent record was broken on September 24th.  I wrote about the Antarctic Ice Area coming close to the record on  September 24th, but  I was 5 days late writing about the Antarctic Ice Extent breaking the record (NSIDC uses Extent and I had not come across the NSIDC data)  and did not post until September 29th.

So of course NSIDC held a news conference on September 27th to announce the new record … didn’t they?

No. No news conference.

Obviously there was a media advisory on the 27th.  Nope.

If you go the press page for NSIDC you will see that Antarctic Ice Extent record is not mentioned until October 2nd, 2012.

Justin Gillis and the NY Times owes a lot of bloggers an apology.