BEST – USA – where is the current 5 year period ranked in terms of TMAX

Published on by sunshinehours1Leave a comment

A continuation of the series on BEST’s TMAX data for USA states and the CONUS and the whole USA.

The most recent 5 years of BEST TMAX data is ranked #6 for the CONUS and #4 for all states. Notice the periods warmer like 51-56 and 31-36. Notice that the current period in .31C colder than the warmest period.

contiguous-united-states – #6

1 2001 – 2006 0.64
2 1996 – 2001 0.61
3 1951 – 1956 0.56
4 1986 – 1991 0.5
5 1931 – 1936 0.46
6 2006 – 2011 0.33
7 1936 – 1941 0.24

Notice how few #1’s there are in the rest of the list.

I think Muller’s own data demolishes his silly CO2 theory.

united-states – #4

alabama – #3
alaska – #4
arizona – #3
arkansas – #5
california – #9
connecticut – #1
district-of-columbia – #3
florida – #2
georgia-(state) – #3
hawaii – #6
idaho – #12
illinois – #7
indiana – #6
iowa – #9
kansas – #9
kentucky – #4
louisiana – #3
maine – #2
maryland – #3
massachusetts – #2
michigan – #5
minnesota – #4
mississippi – #4
missouri – #7
montana – #9
nebraska – #13
nevada – #15
new-hampshire – #2
new-jersey – #2
new-mexico – #4
new-york – #2
north-america – #3
north-carolina – #2
north-dakota – #12
ohio – #5
oklahoma – #6
oregon – #12
pennsylvania – #4
puerto-rico – #2
rhode-island – #1
south-carolina – #2
south-dakota – #16
tennessee – #4
texas – #2
utah – #15
vermont – #2
virginia – #3
washington – #15
west-virginia – #5
wisconsin – #5
wyoming – #12

BEST – USA 5 years averages fall off a cliff continued.

Published on by sunshinehours11 Comment

Continuing from last post. Looking at BESTs TMAX data state by state I noticed that the last 5 years temperatures had fallen off a cliff. Cold!

South Dakota – The current 5 year period is 16th warmest! Wow.

1 1986 – 1991 1.32
2 2001 – 2006 1.23
3 1931 – 1936 0.81
4 1996 – 2001 0.69
5 1936 – 1941 0.52
6 1951 – 1956 0.38
7 1971 – 1976 0.29
8 1976 – 1981 0.25
9 1956 – 1961 0.15
10 1926 – 1931 0.15
11 1941 – 1946 0.1
12 1961 – 1966 0.05
13 1876 – 1881 0.01
14 1896 – 1901 0
15 1906 – 1911 -0.06
16 2006 – 2011 -0.16

Nebraska – 13th

1 2001 – 2006 1.14
2 1986 – 1991 0.89
3 1931 – 1936 0.84
4 1951 – 1956 0.77
5 1996 – 2001 0.66
6 1936 – 1941 0.6
7 1961 – 1966 0.16
8 1941 – 1946 0.14
9 1906 – 1911 0.14
10 1976 – 1981 0.13
11 1971 – 1976 0.04
12 1926 – 1931 -0.02
13 2006 – 2011 -0.04

Kansas – 9th

1 1951 – 1956 1.26
2 2001 – 2006 0.93
3 1931 – 1936 0.9
4 1996 – 2001 0.54
5 1986 – 1991 0.51
6 1936 – 1941 0.37
7 1961 – 1966 0.35
8 1906 – 1911 0.27

Oklahoma – 6th

1 1951 – 1956 1.28
2 1931 – 1936 0.57
3 2001 – 2006 0.54
4 1906 – 1911 0.43
5 1996 – 2001 0.42
6 2006 – 2011 0.39

Texas – 2nd (But look at the #1)

1 1951 – 1956 1.04
2 2006 – 2011 0.69
9 2006 – 2011 0.21

Minnesota – 4th

1 1986 – 1991 1.28
2 2001 – 2006 1.07
3 1996 – 2001 1.04
4 2006 – 2011 0.44

BEST – USA Tmax fell off a cliff on west coast.

Published on by sunshinehours11 Comment

Update: Maybe not just the west coast. I added Montana etc at bottom

Using TMAX data from the new BEST release (here is Oregon)  I calculated 5 year averages for every country/state. TMAX fell off a cliff …

Top 10 TMAX 5 year averages

The current 5 year period is ranked No. 6 for contiguous-united-states

1 2001 – 2006 0.64
2 1996 – 2001 0.61
3 1951 – 1956 0.56
4 1986 – 1991 0.5
5 1931 – 1936 0.46
6 2006 – 2011 0.33
7 1936 – 1941 0.24
8 1941 – 1946 0.12
9 1906 – 1911 0.04
10 1926 – 1931 0.02

No. 15 for washington

1 2001 – 2006 0.9
2 1936 – 1941 0.83
3 1986 – 1991 0.56
4 1921 – 1926 0.51
5 1991 – 1996 0.44
6 1996 – 2001 0.42
7 1931 – 1936 0.32
8 1956 – 1961 0.31
9 1966 – 1971 0.2
10 1941 – 1946 0.2
11 1976 – 1981 0.05
12 1901 – 1906 0.04
13 1961 – 1966 0.03
14 1926 – 1931 -0.02
 15 2006 – 2011 -0.04

No. 12 for oregon

1 2001 – 2006 0.68
2 1986 – 1991 0.56
3 1936 – 1941 0.51
4 1991 – 1996 0.45
5 1931 – 1936 0.4
6 1996 – 2001 0.39
7 1956 – 1961 0.33
8 1921 – 1926 0.23
9 1976 – 1981 0.09
10 1966 – 1971 0.09
11 1961 – 1966 -0.04
12 2006 – 2011 -0.05

Alaska – tied for 3rd. .83C colder than previous 5 year period.

1 2001 – 2006 1.79
2 1976 – 1981 1.25
3 2006 – 2011 0.96
4 1936 – 1941 0.96

California – tied for 8th

1 1956 – 1961 0.54
2 1991 – 1996 0.48
3 1986 – 1991 0.48
4 1931 – 1936 0.47
5 2001 – 2006 0.45
6 1976 – 1981 0.35
7 1926 – 1931 0.28
8 2006 – 2011 0.21
9 1996 – 2001 0.21

Idaho – tied for 11th

1 1986 – 1991 0.72
2 1936 – 1941 0.61
3 1996 – 2001 0.6
4 2001 – 2006 0.57
5 1931 – 1936 0.57
6 1956 – 1961 0.33
7 1991 – 1996 0.31
8 1976 – 1981 0.26
9 1921 – 1926 0.1
10 1951 – 1956 0.03
11 2006 – 2011 0.01
12 1961 – 1966 0.01

Nevada – 15th
1 1956 – 1961 0.52
2 1931 – 1936 0.45
3 1976 – 1981 0.34
4 1991 – 1996 0.3
5 1986 – 1991 0.29
6 2001 – 2006 0.27
7 1996 – 2001 0.25
8 1926 – 1931 0.15
9 1936 – 1941 0.05
10 1946 – 1951 0.02
11 1886 – 1891 0
12 1951 – 1956 -0.01
13 1921 – 1926 -0.04
14 1901 – 1906 -0.04
15 2006 – 2011 -0.06

No. 15 for utah

1 1931 – 1936 0.5
2 1996 – 2001 0.45
3 2001 – 2006 0.37
4 1956 – 1961 0.37
5 1976 – 1981 0.35
6 1951 – 1956 0.28
7 1991 – 1996 0.26
8 1986 – 1991 0.17
9 1936 – 1941 0.1
10 1896 – 1901 0.02
11 1961 – 1966 -0.04
12 1946 – 1951 -0.04
13 1941 – 1946 -0.05
14 1906 – 1911 -0.09
15 2006 – 2011 -0.1

Montana – #9

1 1986 – 1991 1.25
2 1996 – 2001 1.03
3 2001 – 2006 0.92
4 1931 – 1936 0.72
5 1936 – 1941 0.65
6 1956 – 1961 0.38
7 1976 – 1981 0.29
8 1941 – 1946 0.25
9 2006 – 2011 0.2

Wyoming – #12

1 1931 – 1936 0.7
2 2001 – 2006 0.69
3 1996 – 2001 0.67
4 1986 – 1991 0.59
5 1951 – 1956 0.55
6 1936 – 1941 0.4
7 1976 – 1981 0.35
8 1956 – 1961 0.14
9 1961 – 1966 0.11
10 1906 – 1911 0.07
11 1991 – 1996 0.02
12 2006 – 2011 0.01

Arizona – #3 (ok … not a cliff)

1 2001 – 2006 0.61
2 1996 – 2001 0.52
3 2006 – 2011 0.41

Colorado – #7

1 2001 – 2006 0.8
2 1931 – 1936 0.66
3 1951 – 1956 0.62
4 1996 – 2001 0.57
5 1976 – 1981 0.34
6 1961 – 1966 0.16
7 2006 – 2011 0.15

New Mexico tied for #3 (not a cliff)
1 2001 – 2006 0.67
2 1951 – 1956 0.63
3 2006 – 2011 0.57
4 1996 – 2001 0.57

North Dakota – #12 1.61C colder than the warmest period!

1 1986 – 1991 1.73
2 2001 – 2006 1.13
3 1996 – 2001 0.98
4 1931 – 1936 0.53
5 1936 – 1941 0.52
6 1956 – 1961 0.5
7 1976 – 1981 0.35
8 1951 – 1956 0.3
9 1926 – 1931 0.21
10 1941 – 1946 0.19
11 1971 – 1976 0.17
12 2006 – 2011 0.15

BEST July 29, 2012 release – dishonesty? and decade length.

Published on by sunshinehours1Leave a comment

In the new BEST paper on 10 there is map of temperature changes from Jan 2000-Dec 2010 compared to Jan 1950 – Dec 1960.

1)  Why is there idea of a decade 11 years long?

2) Why 1950? I think it is dishonest. I did a quick look at the month temperature anomaly for the USA and UK and calculated the mean for each weird decade.

USA:

1930 -1940 0.39
1950 – 1960 0.17
2000 – 2010 0.65

.48C over 50 years versus .26C over 70 years.

Big difference.

UK:

1940 – 1950 0.32
1950 – 1960 0.17
2000 – 2010 0.93

.76C over 50 years versus .61C over 60 years

Not as big, but still big.

By picking 1950-60 as the starting decade, you start in a big hole and therefore you can tell lies like “1.5F over 50 years”.

BEST – July 29, 2012 release = TMAX 5 year mean colder than late 20s / early 40s

Published on by sunshinehours1Leave a comment

BEST did a new release today (July 29, 2012).  As I’ve been doing with other data sets, I am graphing all the monthly anomalies and calculating the 5 year mean backwards from the most recent month (November 2011 for BEST).

BEST says the most recent 5 year period TMAX in the USA is .5C colder than the previous 5 year period and colder than the 10 period starting around 1933 and extending into the early 1940s. And also colder than the mid 1950s and around 1990. 

Even more interesting, the most current 5 year period is only .57C warmer than the earliest 5 year period in the 1840s.

5 year means in blue boxes on the graph. The value is the departure from the Jan 1951-Dec 1980 average. Data here.

(And thanks to Anthony , this BEST data may be exaggerating the small amount of warming they found).

 

Greenland Temperatures from stations with data from the 1800s.

Published on by sunshinehours1Leave a comment

Greenland Temperatures from stations with data from the 1800s. Updated link here.

It was warmer in the past.

These are the warmest years for each month and season.

Station SEP OCT NOV Autumn DEC JAN FEB Winter MAR APR MAY Spring JUN JUL AUG Summer
Upernavik 1928 1960 1878 2010 1873 1929 1947 1947 1916 1905 1932 1932 2008 2011 1960 2011
Ilulissat 1915 1960 1878 2010 1978 1929 1986 1929 1916 1905 1933 1932 1997 1960 1960 1960
Nuuk 2010 1960 1878 2010 2010 1917 1901 2010 1916 1953 2010 1932 1947 2008 2010 2010
Quaqortoq 2010 1960 2010 2010 1978 2010 1901 2010 1932 1881 1935 1932 1929 2003 1960 1929
Tasiilaq 1939 1915 2002 1941 1933 1987 1932 1929 1929 1926 1933 1929 1932 1939 2010 2003

Nunavut – Yes it was warming, but 1930 and 1931 were warm too

Published on by sunshinehours1Leave a comment

There have been many claims about extreme warming in the arctic. So I decided to look at the Environment Canada data for Nunavut.

I used the stations with 1971-2000 Normals. I scraped the data from here. The Normals stations have data in the D column.

2010 was very warm. 2011 and 2012 (so far) not so much. Both are cooler than 1930,1931,1940 and 1947. I admit there isn’t much data for 1930 to 1931, but the “D” stations are supposed to be more reliable.

 

How cold is the 48 States for each month compared to the record temperature – NOAA data #2

Published on by sunshinehours1Leave a comment

This post is identical to the previous post, but it has the age of the record. 0/0 means current record.

92/-13.6 means the record was 92 years old and October 2011 in Alabama was -13.6F colder than the 1919 record.

Using NOAA data (mean temperature), how cold are the last 12 months (Jul 2011 to Jun 2012) compared to the warmest month.

For example, October 2011 in Alabama was -13.6F colder than the warmest October in Alabama– 1919

October 1919 was 74.0F

October 2011 was 60.4F

Current Temperature minus Record Temperature

If the value is 0 / 0  the record for the mean temperature was set in the current month.

State Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Alabama 62 / -10.4 85 / -6.9 105 / -0.2 45 / -3.4 79 / -2.7 98 / -5.9 81 / -1.8 4 / -2.8 86 / -10.8 92 / -13.6 26 / -6 78 / -7.2
Arizona 9 / -4.4 17 / -5.4 8 / -6.7 23 / -3.9 12 / -2.8 116 / -4.2 8 / -3.3 0 / 0 112 / -2.8 8 / -5 16 / -5.9 115 / -9.4
Arkansas 105 / -4.3 36 / -5.5 0 / 0 116 / -2.9 50 / -1 59 / -5.3 57 / -0.6 57 / -1.8 86 / -9.6 48 / -8.2 102 / -5.3 27 / -7.3
California 26 / -3.1 49 / -5 78 / -7.6 86 / -4.8 11 / -4.7 116 / -6.4 112 / -4.8 44 / -1.8 2 / -0.1 8 / -3.3 16 / -7.2 61 / -5.8
Colorado 9 / -2.8 58 / -9.6 8 / -0.2 66 / -0.8 78 / -3.7 0 / 0 8 / -2.3 0 / 0 13 / -3.3 48 / -6.2 62 / -6.1 31 / -11
Connecticut 80 / -4.9 14 / -0.6 0 / 0 91 / -2.2 21 / -1.8 87 / -3.8 98 / -2.8 98 / -3.4 50 / -1 98 / -6.2 5 / -0.5 10 / -0.6
Delaware 62 / -6 36 / -1.2 91 / -1.6 1 / -3.5 8 / -1.3 2 / -4.4 0 / 0 111 / -2.6 81 / -1.9 4 / -6.6 26 / -2.1 27 / -0.6
Florida 75 / -9.6 80 / -4 105 / -0.5 104 / -4.3 107 / -1.2 14 / -4.6 13 / -1.1 1 / 0 86 / -2.6 92 / -7.9 25 / -6 80 / -6.2
Georgia 62 / -9.3 85 / -6.5 0 / 0 10 / -2.4 116 / -2.7 60 / -7 25 / -1.8 4 / -1 86 / -9.7 92 / -13 26 / -7.2 80 / -5.8
Idaho 59 / -6.4 78 / -7.5 78 / -5.2 78 / -4.4 115 / -7.3 94 / -6.1 4 / -7.3 8 / -2.2 21 / -1.7 23 / -5.7 12 / -8.1 94 / -10.1
Illinois 6 / -6.3 14 / -5 0 / 0 2 / -4.4 50 / -1.5 78 / -6 75 / -3.2 64 / -6.5 86 / -9.1 48 / -9.2 80 / -4.1 88 / -4
Indiana 6 / -7.1 58 / -4.9 0 / 0 116 / -4.7 116 / -0.9 78 / -5.4 75 / -2.1 64 / -6.3 86 / -8.3 64 / -7.9 80 / -3 88 / -4.1
Iowa 6 / -6.4 58 / -7.3 0 / 0 97 / -3.5 78 / -3.8 79 / -5.6 75 / -4.6 64 / -7.8 80 / -9.6 48 / -8.8 10 / -8.7 80 / -3.7
Kansas 6 / -5.7 82 / -9.2 0 / 0 31 / -2.5 50 / -2.4 60 / -3.8 77 / -2 75 / -4.1 80 / -10.5 48 / -8.7 12 / -6.9 54 / -6.2
Kentucky 62 / -6.7 80 / -5.8 0 / 0 116 / -5.6 116 / -2.3 60 / -6 110 / -1.8 4 / -5.2 86 / -9.7 92 / -9.3 80 / -3.9 88 / -4.9
Louisiana 62 / -7 80 / -6.2 105 / -1.1 45 / -2.4 79 / -1.3 1 / -3.5 13 / -1.2 0 / 0 100 / -5.3 92 / -9.3 84 / -4.4 78 / -9
Maine 99 / -6.5 31 / -5.9 66 / -1.3 2 / -2.5 101 / -3.9 82 / -5.6 59 / -3.5 74 / -4.8 50 / -3 98 / -9.9 80 / -0.4 111 / -2.9
Maryland 62 / -7.5 36 / -1.8 91 / -0.5 18 / -4.4 8 / -1.5 69 / -4.5 56 / -0.1 111 / -3.9 81 / -3.3 4 / -6.9 26 / -1.9 27 / -2
Massachusetts 99 / -5.6 14 / -0.8 66 / -0.3 67 / -2 68 / -1.7 82 / -4.4 56 / -1.9 74 / -3.6 50 / -2.1 64 / -5.1 85 / -0.8 5 / -1.7
Michigan 6 / -5 14 / -4.2 0 / 0 97 / -5.9 116 / -3.7 93 / -4.5 90 / -3.8 64 / -5.2 103 / -6.4 111 / -7.2 10 / -3.8 88 / -3.5
Minnesota 6 / -5.9 14 / -7 0 / 0 97 / -6 35 / -5.7 79 / -5.3 75 / -3.3 111 / -5.1 114 / -6.2 48 / -6.2 10 / -7.7 72 / -2.1
Mississippi 62 / -8.2 80 / -7.3 0 / 0 116 / -3.6 116 / -3 98 / -5 81 / -1.3 87 / -1.5 86 / -10.3 92 / -11.6 84 / -4.7 78 / -8.4
Missouri 6 / -5.4 82 / -5.3 0 / 0 31 / -3.2 50 / -2.7 60 / -5.7 77 / -3.1 75 / -6 80 / -9.7 48 / -9.6 102 / -5.3 80 / -4.9
Montana 6 / -5.6 21 / -8.8 26 / -1.8 25 / -3.6 78 / -9.1 24 / -8.4 75 / -7.1 40 / -3.4 13 / -2.8 48 / -3.9 62 / -9.1 115 / -3.8
Nebraska 6 / -7 58 / -12 0 / 0 31 / -2.6 78 / -6.3 79 / -3.8 75 / -5.3 74 / -5.6 114 / -9.1 48 / -7.4 12 / -6.9 103 / -9.3
Nevada 9 / -6 17 / -8.4 78 / -7 78 / -3.9 11 / -3.8 94 / -4 80 / -5.4 77 / -1.6 2 / -0.6 23 / -4.7 62 / -8.1 94 / -8.4
New Hampshire 80 / -4.9 31 / -2.5 0 / 0 71 / -2.2 101 / -1.9 36 / -4.5 56 / -1.9 74 / -3.4 50 / -2.7 64 / -5.1 5 / -0.3 5 / -1.9
New Jersey 80 / -6.9 14 / -1.1 0 / 0 2 / -3.3 21 / -1.5 2 / -4.5 56 / -0.3 6 / -3.1 50 / -2.3 4 / -6.1 5 / -0.6 5 / -1.5
New Mexico 103 / -3.3 55 / -7.5 102 / -2.7 10 / -1.1 16 / -3.9 22 / -0.8 8 / -0.3 0 / 0 1 / -2.1 61 / -5.5 84 / -4.2 31 / -9.4
New York 80 / -6.8 28 / -0.8 0 / 0 91 / -6.2 101 / -1.1 63 / -4.7 90 / -2.2 56 / -3.9 50 / -3.4 64 / -6.1 80 / -0.9 5 / -2.8
North Carolina 62 / -8.7 85 / -5.9 67 / -0.7 10 / -3.8 116 / -2.5 60 / -6.5 18 / -1.2 111 / -2.8 90 / -5.2 92 / -10.5 26 / -6.8 55 / -4.1
North Dakota 6 / -6.3 58 / -9.1 102 / -0.5 25 / -5 35 / -8.4 24 / -9 75 / -8.6 28 / -5.2 114 / -4.8 48 / -6.6 10 / -6.8 72 / -2.7
Ohio 80 / -7 14 / -4.2 0 / 0 116 / -5.7 21 / -0.8 78 / -5.3 77 / -0.7 64 / -4.6 80 / -5 64 / -7.6 80 / -2.3 88 / -3
Oklahoma 6 / -3.8 58 / -7.6 0 / 0 6 / -1.8 116 / -2.8 59 / -6 0 / 0 0 / 0 80 / -8.6 48 / -8.1 12 / -6.3 46 / -5.4
Oregon 59 / -5 49 / -6.5 78 / -8 78 / -5.4 20 / -6.8 94 / -7.8 105 / -6.9 44 / -2.3 0 / 0 23 / -5.8 12 / -6 78 / -7.3
Pennsylvania 80 / -9.3 14 / -2.5 0 / 0 91 / -6.1 68 / -0.9 69 / -5.3 56 / -1.2 111 / -4.5 80 / -3.3 64 / -7.3 80 / -3.2 88 / -3.2
Rhode Island 80 / -5.8 28 / -2.1 0 / 0 2 / -2.6 2 / -2.8 2 / -5.4 1 / -0.9 6 / -2.3 50 / -0.6 64 / -4 36 / -1.3 83 / -4.1
South Carolina 38 / -8.8 85 / -6.6 67 / 0 10 / -3.3 116 / -4 60 / -7.2 18 / -1.5 4 / -2.4 86 / -7.5 92 / -12.7 26 / -7.6 55 / -4.7
South Dakota 6 / -7 58 / -11 0 / 0 117 / -2.2 78 / -9.9 79 / -5.2 75 / -8 74 / -6.1 114 / -7.7 48 / -6.3 12 / -7.9 72 / -3.5
Tennessee 62 / -7.4 85 / -5.9 0 / 0 116 / -3.4 50 / -2.3 60 / -6.8 81 / -1.4 4 / -5 86 / -11.1 92 / -10.9 26 / -4.8 80 / -6.2
Texas 89 / -5.3 12 / -6.2 105 / -3.2 45 / -0.5 16 / -3 1 / -2.6 0 / 0 0 / 0 100 / -3.2 64 / -4.9 84 / -6.3 78 / -8.5
Utah 9 / -3.8 105 / -7.1 8 / -2.6 20 / -3.3 78 / -3.3 5 / -0.9 8 / -4.6 4 / -0.5 21 / -1 23 / -4.7 62 / -5.5 94 / -9.6
Vermont 80 / -7 31 / -4 66 / 0 67 / -3.7 37 / -1.6 63 / -4.7 90 / -3.3 74 / -4.1 50 / -3.6 64 / -5.3 102 / -3.9 5 / -3.2
Virginia 62 / -8.6 36 / -3.5 67 / -0.4 58 / -3.4 59 / -1.6 2 / -5.9 77 / -0.8 111 / -3.7 81 / -5 92 / -9.3 26 / -4.4 55 / -4.3
Washington 59 / -6.9 21 / -5.6 20 / -7.4 78 / -6.4 54 / -7.3 20 / -8.7 105 / -9 44 / -3.6 44 / -1.3 110 / -5.2 112 / -9.6 111 / -7.4
West Virginia 62 / -10.1 80 / -4.3 0 / 0 58 / -5.2 116 / -1.5 69 / -6.7 110 / -1.7 111 / -3.7 111 / -4.7 92 / -9.4 26 / -4.4 55 / -4.4
Wisconsin 6 / -7.2 14 / -5.7 0 / 0 97 / -6.4 35 / -3.5 79 / -4.9 90 / -2.4 64 / -5.9 80 / -7.2 48 / -7.5 10 / -6.6 88 / -3.2
Wyoming 59 / -4.2 58 / -9.5 0 / 0 69 / -1.1 78 / -6.6 24 / -3.7 4 / -3 8 / -1.2 13 / -2.8 48 / -4.9 62 / -9.9 115 / -10.6
Northeast Region 80 / -7.1 14 / -1.4 0 / 0 91 / -4.2 101 / -1.1 69 / -3.5 56 / -1.4 74 / -3.4 50 / -2.9 64 / -5.7 80 / -1.2 5 / -2.2
East North CentralRegion 6 / -6.1 14 / -5.8 0 / 0 97 / -5.5 35 / -3.6 79 / -4.7 75 / -2.3 64 / -5.6 80 / -7 48 / -7.2 10 / -6.8 88 / -2.4
Central Region 6 / -5.6 82 / -4.2 0 / 0 116 / -4.1 50 / -1.4 60 / -5.2 77 / -1.6 75 / -4.6 86 / -8.4 64 / -7.9 80 / -3.8 88 / -3.9
Southeast Region 62 / -8.8 85 / -5.1 67 / -0.1 58 / -2.7 116 / -1.8 60 / -5.6 18 / -0.9 4 / -1.8 86 / -6.7 92 / -11.1 26 / -6 80 / -4.8
West North Central Region 6 / -5.5 58 / -9.6 102 / -0.2 25 / -2 78 / -8.2 24 / -5.8 75 / -6 28 / -3.6 13 / -4.4 48 / -5.5 12 / -8 72 / -4.9
South Region 89 / -3.8 82 / -5.9 105 / -0.6 6 / -1.1 116 / -1.5 59 / -3.6 0 / 0 0 / 0 100 / -5.4 64 / -6.2 102 / -4.9 78 / -7.4
Southwest Region 9 / -3.1 17 / -6.2 8 / -3 23 / -1 78 / -2.3 116 / -0.4 8 / -2.5 0 / 0 1 / -1.3 61 / -5 62 / -5.2 31 / -9.3
Northwest Region 59 / -5.9 49 / -5.8 78 / -6.8 78 / -5.4 54 / -6.7 94 / -6.9 4 / -7 44 / -2.3 21 / -0.7 23 / -5.4 112 / -7.3 94 / -7.8
West Region 9 / -4.2 49 / -5.9 78 / -7.3 78 / -3.9 11 / -4.3 116 / -4.2 80 / -4.3 53 / -1.4 2 / -0.3 8 / -3.6 16 / -7.4 61 / -6.7
USA Contiguous 48 States 6 / -3.22 58 / -3.92 0 / 0 6 / -0.67 78 / -1.03 79 / -1.08 75 / -0.42 28 / -0.06 13 / -3.04 48 / -4.32 12 / -4.21 72 / -2.81